That’s a lot of votes and comments.

Is there a search engine that doesn’t leech off of some huge corporate API?

It was probably the KYS initials.

Old, but still relevant:

That’s exactly my point. Reddit is still shit, and you can’t exactly fork the data, because they’ve locked down the API.

Bluesky could do the exact same thing.

Bluesky is centralized but it seems like its design is committed enough to open technology that it would take them a long time to walk it back

Let’s not forget that Reddit’s code is open source. Just because their technology is open doesn’t mean that the data, usage, and network are protected.

You use hyphens because they look cool.

I use em dashes because Oxford Standard Style Guide for English dictates how it should be used.

We are not the same.

Alexis left Reddit suddenly with some weird excuse, too. I think he got word of the stock plan and immediately jumped ship.

You really trust the US government to control your communications? Especially given the last 20 years?

No, I don’t trust right-wing Nazis to control my communications. And I sure as fuck trust the government more than I trust greedy corporations. The problem is that the corporations have been fucking up the capitalistic/democratic balance for the last 50 years.

The raw SMTP landscape on the internet is such a shitshow. Setting up a SMTP server requires so many goddamn condoms that you might as well just give up and start using some other professional email service. Or you set it up just to forward email to a GMail account, and even then, Gmail bitches about how much spam you’re forwarding it and blocks you for a time.

They have conferences about ActivityPub. Why isn’t W3C trying to fix this mess in newer backwards-incompatible versions? The time to do it is now, not later, because it would involve a major version and years of pushing for adoption. The lack of standardization of basic concepts is why integrations of different types of implementations is a broken mess, which is the whole fucking point of ActivityPub! Now, we have to compete with ATProto, which has different kinds of problems, and it’s very possible that it just wins out and kills ActivityPub.

This reminds of the early days of SMTP, where there was zero thought behind security, and that created an entire spam industry.

PeerTube integration into Lemmy is still shit, poorly implemented, and rarely linked by Lemmy admins.

It’s a thing you can look up on search engines or Wikipedia very easily: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/VTuber

The internet is essentially an infinite world

I think this worldview is part of the problem. Nothing is infinite, not even the Internet. The tiny pillars that maintain critical pieces will eventually move on. We used to joke that the Internet is forever, but it’s not. Data decays and dies. Old web pages are lost.

Archive.org, Wikipedia, Linux, free and open-source things we take for granted could just disappear.

Even the scope of the Internet isn’t infinite. Just because something is created doesn’t mean that people will see it, and not everything you can think of exists on the Internet.

It’s large, for sure, but it has boundaries. Boundaries we can see in macroscopic forms.

you become nothing.

You are not nothing because you’re not lost in an infinite landscape. Again, the Internet has boundaries, and singular actions that nobody has seen can happen.

I still don’t understand how the PDS concept matters in an interconnected network of replies. Conversations are threaded, and that “personal data” needs all parties involved in the chain to move to this new thing at the same time. It’s not going to happen.

Tesla isn’t really losing anything except a bunch of fake market value. It was incredibly overvalued, and now this market correction is sorting itself out.

People who are on Nebula already made it in Youtube and they’re so big that they just want to make more money.

Nebula is a gated community for YouTubers who have already made it. They have no avenue for adding more users, like the wealth of good indie YouTubers that are up and coming, and they don’t even seem to want to add to their own curated list themselves. Their community has been stagnated for years. All they have done is forced their current membership to constantly advertise for them on YouTube.

Nebula is not the answer and never will be. I don’t even see a point in going there, because I already have these same channels on YouTube.

I don’t really like the use of a strawman to argument against in the article. I don’t care that it has a name and looks like an owl. It’s still a strawman, and it’s rather condescending.

Getting back to the whole PDS bit, I don’t really get the importance, given our current scenarios. We are protecting against the enshittification of communication mediums that people use on a regular basis, by giving them a chance to jump ship and move to somewhere else. Or to somehow prevent the enshittification from happening in the first place.

That’s it. Don’t add to this massive scope creep, by inventing other goals.

While the app is centralized, the data isn’t completely centralized. In ATProto your data is written to your own PDS ( Personal Data Server ), and that PDS can be hosted by anyone. So if the app goes down, you can still have your data on your PDS.

What good is this PDS when the app goes down? Let’s say that Bluesky gets bought out and everybody wants to get rid of it. You have your own PDS, fine. You find this cool new ATProto-compatible service that a lot of people are jumping on.

Problem: Your PDS is useless. It’s not like you can link these disconnected replies in your data stream to the new service. Not everybody in the reply chain moved over, or they didn’t move over at the same time as you. What the hell in this PDS is actually useful to a new service? Start time? Number of replies? Block lists that no longer apply? And this new service is actually going to trust all of those numbers? Fuck no! Never trust user data!

Well, if Omnivore was an ATProto app, and they shut down their server, all of the users would still have their data on their PDS in a standardized format. At that point, any other developers can come in and run another app, or even the same app if it was Open Source like omnivore, and access all of the existing data already on your PDS when you login.

No! Wrong! Try again! Your data is just your data. Conversations have relationships. Relationships have links. Disconnected data points are fucking useless!

When somebody lets you “Login with ATProto”, unlike the “Login with Google” button, it actually lets you login with your very own PDS.

Oh, great… we’ve introduced login poisoning potential. Yes, trust this random user that they authenticated properly with a session token. I did not see the word “security” once in this article, which makes me think they haven’t even considered it.

The “Login with Google” button has been so useful and yet so horrible for the freedom of the web. Why does google get to be the gatekeeper to all of our web logins?

Because Google at least understands session security and login practices. What’s the one absolute law on the internet that OWASP hammers home over and over again?

Never trust user input!

You can’t decentralize authentication to such a degree that it’s personalized. There has to be a semi-centralized authority. With Lemmy, it’s the Lemmy instance that we choose.

Gah, there is so much wrong here that I don’t feel like trying to comment on every single point here. This article is trying to answer the wrong questions and literally using a strawman to pretend that they know what the public is asking about.

Maybe start with “What the hell is ATProto?”

I didn’t really see anything block-worthy in that comment.

The top oligarchs like Elon barely even registered it.

Elon admitted to Jon Rogan a week or two ago that he’s using his kid as a human shield to protect himself from an assassin.

If you wanna know what they’re afraid of, look at where they spend money - buying politicians and opposing attempts to regulate them and break up their monopolies.

Actually, mob justice and dying actually does scare them. It’s the one thing they can’t just buy their way out of.